Valencia
Las Provincias - 05/21/1911 - A. RALLO Las Fallas relations between neighbors and sometimes are a little stormy. There are few times when cohabitation ends in the courts. In the vast majority of cases it is disturbed by noise. The decision of the Audiencia Provincial de Valencia confirms once more the problem. Canned failure pay 2,000 euros for moral damages caused to a neighbor's property. The court thus confirmed the decision of the district court, which also ruled in favor of the injured.
The commission is Berenguer Mallol street where they had rented at the material time low of that property. From January 2009 to May 2010 failure caused noise nuisance to the plaintiffs. The neighbors claimed, in addition to compensation, soundproof facilities. Now the latter is no longer necessary. The fault, however, denied there was any trouble and that in any case, these were not accredited. Moreover, he argued that it was a revenge of the residents who had long belonged to the board of the commission. Claimed that they moved "the resentment and bitterness."
The Court analyzed separately each of the issues proposed by the failure. Regarding the inconvenience, the court considers it proven that the bass is made activities were "now." And not only by statements from those affected, but by the homeowners, the local police and the city, it is shown that festivals were held, paella contests, play-backs and birthdays "not subject to reasonable hours and with full knowledge of discomfort. " Similarlyintervention consists of local police and laboratory acoustic measurements. Regarding the data-taken on the day of the filing of the faller more-are well above the levels authorized by the City.
"In the new manor has not been any complaints from neighbors"
Las Provincias - 21/05/1911
The commission says fallera of Algirós not understand how justice can be given by good demand for the complainants, who claimed to suffer from depression, "if to prove moral damages did not provide, to our knowledge, no medical report attesting to such status. What they did is send the police constantly, and include an expert report for measuring sound. "
The falleros insist that the complainants were previously members of the committee, "dropped out and signed up for another failure next time, and that's when the complaints began. We do not understand how a member of own party denounce the failure to do tests and actions. "
0 comments:
Post a Comment